| 1957 Detroit Lions | George Wilson | |
| 1958 Baltimore Colts | Weeb Ewbank | |
| 1959 Green Bay Packers | Vince Lombardi | |
| 1960 Philadelphia Eagles | Lawrence "Buck" Shaw | |
| 1961 New York Giants | Allie Sherman | |
| 1962 New York Giants | Allie Sherman | |
| 1963 Chicago Bears | George Halas | |
| 1964 Baltimore Colts | Don Shula | |
| 1965 Chicago Bears | George Halas | |
| 1966 Dallas Cowboys | Tom Landry | |
| 1967 Los Angeles Rams | George Allen | |
| 1967 Baltimore Colts | Don Shula | |
| 1968 Baltimore Colts | Don Shula | |
| 1969 Minnesota Vikings | Bud Grant | |
| 1970 Cincinnati Bengals | Paul Brown | |
| 1971 Washington Redskins | George Allen | |
| 1972 Miami Dolphins | Don Shula | |
| 1973 Los Angeles Rams | Chuck Knox | |
| 1974 St. Louis Cardinals | Don Coryell | |
| 1975 Baltimore Colts | Ted Marchibroda | |
| 1976 Cleveland Browns | Forrest Gregg | |
| 1977 Denver Broncos | Red Miller | |
| 1978 Seattle Seahawks | Jack Patera | |
| 1979 Washington Redskins | Jack Pardee | |
| 1980 Buffalo Bills | Chuck Knox | |
| 1982 Washington Redskins | Joe Gibbs | |
| 1983 Washington Redskins | Joe Gibbs | |
| 1984 Seattle Seahawks | Chuck Knox | |
| 1985 Chicago Bears | Mike Ditka | |
| 1986 New York Giants | Bill Parcells | |
| 1987 New Orleans Saints | Jim E. Mora (Sr.) | |
| 1988 Chicago Bears | Mike Ditka | |
| 1989 Green Bay Packers | Lindy Infante | |
| 1990 Dallas Cowboys | Jimmy Johnson | |
| 1991 Detroit Lions | Wayne Fontes | |
| 1992 Pittsburgh Steelers | Bill Cowher | |
| 1993 New York Giants | Dan Reeves | |
| 1994 New England Patriots | Bill Parcells | |
| 1995 Philadelphia Eagles | Ray Rhodes | |
| 1996 Carolina Panthers | Dom Capers | |
| 1997 New York Giants | Jim Fassel | |
| 1998 Atlanta Falcons | Dan Reeves | |
| 1999 St. Louis Rams | Dick Vermeil | |
| 2000 New Orleans Saints | Jim Haslett | |
| 2001 Chicago Bears | Dick Jauron | |
| 2002 Philadelphia Eagles | Andy Reid | |
| 2003 New England Patriots | Bill Belichick | |
| 2004 San Diego Chargers | Marty Schottenheimer | |
| 2005 Chicago Bears | Lovie Smith | |
| 2006 New Orleans Saints | Sean Payton | |
| 2007 New England Patriots | Bill Belichick | |
| 2008 Atlanta Falcons | Mike Smith | |
| 2009 Cincinnati Bengals | Marvin Lewis | |
| 2010 New England Patriots | Bill Belichick | |
| 2011 San Francisco 49ers | Jim Harbaugh | |
| 2012 Indianapolis Colts | Bruce Arians | |
| 2013 Carolina Panthers | Ron Rivera | |
| 2014 Arizona Cardinals | Bruce Arians | |
| 2015 Carolina Panthers | Ron Rivera | |
| 2016 Dallas Cowboys | Jason Garrett | |
| 2017 Los Angeles Rams | Sean McVay | |
| 2018 Chicago Bears | Matt Nagy | |
| 2019 Baltimore Ravens | John Harbaugh | |
| 2020 Cleveland Browns | Kevin Stefanski | |
| 2021 Tennessee Titans | Mike Vrabel | |
| 2022 New York Giants | Brian Daboll | |
| 2023 Cleveland Browns | Kevin Stefanski | |